Art/Style/Travel Diaries

The Play That Goes Wrong makes a brilliant mess onstage

In trying to make a show about everything going wrong, it ends up demonstrating just how much can go right

The Play That Goes Wrong is the play that goes on, and thankfully so, because it gave me one of the most delightful times inside a theater. First staged in London in 2012, the comedy was conceived by Henry Lewis, Jonathan Sayer, and Henry Shields, with Mark Bell directing its original production. More than a decade later, it finally debuts in Manila through GMG Productions, directed by Hannah Sharkey. Despite the years between its premiere and local staging, the play’s appeal remains very much intact. It knows what it wants to be and commits to it wholeheartedly: a theatrical spectacle that finds comedy in the most spectacular ways things can go wrong. 

The production’s greatest strength lies in the cohesiveness of its spectacle. Its script, cast, and production design work hand in hand to deliver the humor, with the actors’ performances equally dependent on the physical space they occupy and the many ways it can be manipulated. This is particularly evident in Nigel Hook’s ingenious set design, which opens with a fully furnished private study. A sofa sits at the center of the room, placed over a carpet, with a fireplace and decorated mantel, framed portraits along the walls, a grandfather clock, and a single door leading out of the room. The bookshelf in the corner doesn’t just serve as a mere backdrop but turns out to be a passage to a secret room. The stage also features a split-level set-up, with an elevator connecting the study to a second-floor library. This seemingly perfect set-up is also designed to fall apart, with collapsing structures and malfunctioning fixtures triggering much of the chaos and physical comedy that follow.

Understanding the comedy first requires recognizing its central conceit: a play within a play. The story follows the Cornley Drama Society, an amateur theater group staging a 1920s murder mystery titled The Murder at Haversham Manor. Set precisely in the crime scene at the Haversham residence, the story revolves around the mysterious death of Charles Haversham (Liam Horrigan), played by the society’s Jonathan, whose fiancée, Florence Colleymoore (Mikkie Bradshaw-Volante), is portrayed by Sandra. The investigation also involves Florence’s brother, Thomas (Owen Jenkins), played by Robert; Charles’ brother, Cecil (Sebastiano Pitruzzello), played by Max; and the household butler, Perkins (Tom Hayward), played by Dennis. 

Meanwhile, Chris, the society’s director, takes on the role of Inspector Carter (Tom Babbage), who arrives to investigate Charles’ supposed murder. Outside the production, Annie (Olivia Charalambous) serves as the stage manager, while Trevor (Jake Curran) handles the technical operations. By having the actors juggle their identities as Cornley Drama Society members and their respective characters, the play creates two layers of comedy, with the performers’ own clumsiness and shortcomings spilling into a production that is supposed to be as serious as a murder mystery.

When the show finally gets underway, the set design proves just as instrumental to the comedy as the actors themselves. Its mechanics are timed with remarkable precision, turning even the simplest movements into opportunities for physical gags. The actors trip over the carpet, struggle with a door that seems to have a mind of its own, and scramble to catch wall-mounted fixtures just as they threaten to fall. These stunts require impeccable coordination with the production team, particularly in the scenes where Annie must catch candlesticks through holes in the wall. Unfortunately for her, the catches happen at the most inconvenient moments, including when the fireplace mantel becomes essential to the scene. Left with no choice, she has to serve as its human substitute, and her increasingly bewildered expression only makes the situation funnier.

Yet the production also knows when to move beyond these seemingly silly mishaps and deliver moments that genuinely leave the audience in awe. Some of its most impressive sequences almost resemble stage magic. In one particularly chaotic scene, Inspector Carter and Thomas struggle to keep themselves upright in the second-floor library as Cecil accidentally removes the supporting pole, leaving the entire structure precariously suspended. In another, Florence appears to vanish from the stage, only to reappear inside the grandfather clock just seconds after standing in full view of the audience.

Yet the production also knows when to move beyond these seemingly silly mishaps and deliver moments that genuinely leave the audience in awe

While The Play That Goes Wrong does not necessarily aim to impart a larger lesson, nor does it need to, its premise makes an interesting case of its own. There is an irony in how the Cornley Drama Society’s production falls apart because of its limited resources, while the actual production showcases what theater can achieve when equipped with the right resources. In trying to make a show about everything going wrong, it ends up demonstrating just how much can go right when a production has the means and creativity to bring its vision to life.

It is also worth mentioning the brilliance of the script, which makes clever use of foreshadowing, as when Charles repeatedly appears in the wrong scenes holding a shotgun. It finds fresh ways to make recurring lines funny and turns the actors’ forgotten lines and overlapping dialogue into part of the comedy, as the Cornley members cover for one another onstage. The production is equally playful in how it breaks the fourth wall, with the actors moving seamlessly between their murder mystery characters, their identities as members of the Society, and their roles as performers addressing the audience directly. Some of these exchanges even incorporate timely references to Manila, making the jokes feel more immediate to the local audience.

Of course, one of its most notable attempts to connect with the local audience comes through the casting of Bradshaw-Volante, the lone Filipino performer among an otherwise foreign cast. She fits seamlessly into the ensemble while taking on the challenge of portraying an ambitious Florence, whose exaggerated expressions and theatrical poses are all part of her attempts to steal the spotlight. Bradshaw-Volante balances this larger-than-life performance with Florence’s conniving nature, gradually revealing a character with plenty of schemes up her sleeve.

The cast at curtain call (Photo by Trixia Policarpio)

Despite the many mishaps that threaten to derail their production, the members of the Cornley Drama Society remain determined to see their show through. Consequently, The Play That Goes Wrong proves that a show must not only go on, but can make a spectacular night out of everything that goes wrong.

‘The Play That Goes Wrong’ has its last two performances Saturday, 21 Nov., 3 and 8 pm, and Sunday, 22 Nov., 1:30 and 6 pm at the Theatre at Solaire. Check https://premier.ticketworld.com.ph/ for tickets.

About author

Articles

Trixia Policarpio writes about films, books, lifestyle, and the messy, beautiful parts of relationships. She also crafts fiction that loves to bend genres with a touch of speculative element. Follow her on Instragram @trixiaxx.

    Newsletter
    Sign up for our Newsletter

    Sign up for Diarist.ph’s Weekly Digest and get the best of Diarist.ph, tailored for you.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *